{"lineage":"DU/2012/161","path":"arti(31)","returned":20,"limit":20,"truncated":false,"results":[{"id":"cbosa:0A93287619","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 170/22","judgmentDate":"2024-11-19","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 19 listopada 2024 r., II OSK 170/22 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A0A93287619","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 19 listopada 2024 r., II OSK 170/22"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/0A93287619","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_170/22"},{"id":"cbosa:EBC33E59DA","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2872/21","judgmentDate":"2024-10-24","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 24 października 2024 r., II OSK 2872/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3AEBC33E59DA","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 24 października 2024 r., II OSK 2872/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/EBC33E59DA","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2872/21"},{"id":"cbosa:8333B53422","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 887/23","judgmentDate":"2024-06-27","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 27 czerwca 2024 r., II OSK 887/23 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A8333B53422","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 27 czerwca 2024 r., II OSK 887/23"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/8333B53422","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_887/23"},{"id":"cbosa:A1958207D2","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 1933/21","judgmentDate":"2024-06-07","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 7 czerwca 2024 r., II OSK 1933/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3AA1958207D2","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 7 czerwca 2024 r., II OSK 1933/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/A1958207D2","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_1933/21"},{"id":"cbosa:495D667225","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2187/21","judgmentDate":"2024-06-07","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 7 czerwca 2024 r., II OSK 2187/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A495D667225","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 7 czerwca 2024 r., II OSK 2187/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/495D667225","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2187/21/2024-06-07"},{"id":"cbosa:069F86C882","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 530/23","judgmentDate":"2024-04-15","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 15 kwietnia 2024 r., II OSK 530/23 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A069F86C882","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 15 kwietnia 2024 r., II OSK 530/23"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/069F86C882","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_530/23"},{"id":"cbosa:E45DF2885B","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 1129/22","judgmentDate":"2024-04-09","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 9 kwietnia 2024 r., II OSK 1129/22 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3AE45DF2885B","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 9 kwietnia 2024 r., II OSK 1129/22"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/E45DF2885B","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_1129/22"},{"id":"cbosa:8086007867","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 417/23","judgmentDate":"2024-04-09","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 9 kwietnia 2024 r., II OSK 417/23 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A8086007867","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 9 kwietnia 2024 r., II OSK 417/23"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/8086007867","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_417/23"},{"id":"cbosa:13FB3A42A6","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2262/23","judgmentDate":"2024-03-12","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 12 marca 2024 r., II OSK 2262/23 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A13FB3A42A6","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 12 marca 2024 r., II OSK 2262/23"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/13FB3A42A6","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2262/23"},{"id":"cbosa:4522389515","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 1345/21","judgmentDate":"2024-01-25","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 25 stycznia 2024 r., II OSK 1345/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A4522389515","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 25 stycznia 2024 r., II OSK 1345/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/4522389515","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_1345/21"},{"id":"cbosa:1741C4A4CB","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 1162/22","judgmentDate":"2023-10-18","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 18 października 2023 r., II OSK 1162/22 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A1741C4A4CB","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 18 października 2023 r., II OSK 1162/22"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/1741C4A4CB","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_1162/22"},{"id":"cbosa:3E976A909D","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2217/21","judgmentDate":"2023-10-12","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 12 października 2023 r., II OSK 2217/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A3E976A909D","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 12 października 2023 r., II OSK 2217/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/3E976A909D","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2217/21"},{"id":"cbosa:43C9C24A62","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2780/21","judgmentDate":"2023-02-07","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 7 lutego 2023 r., II OSK 2780/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A43C9C24A62","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 7 lutego 2023 r., II OSK 2780/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/43C9C24A62","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2780/21"},{"id":"cbosa:6315AEB953","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2463/21","judgmentDate":"2023-01-04","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 4 stycznia 2023 r., II OSK 2463/21 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A6315AEB953","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 4 stycznia 2023 r., II OSK 2463/21"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/6315AEB953","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2463/21"},{"id":"cbosa:00E017B719","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Wojewódzki Sąd Administracyjny w Warszawie","docket":"IV SA/Wa 2685/20","judgmentDate":"2021-03-23","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok WSA w Warszawie","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok WSA w Warszawie z 23 marca 2021 r., IV SA/Wa 2685/20 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A00E017B719","designation":"wyrok Wojewódzkiego Sądu Administracyjnego w Warszawie z dnia 23 marca 2021 r., IV SA/Wa 2685/20"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/00E017B719","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/wojewodzki-sad-administracyjny-w-warszawie/IV_SA/Wa_2685/20"},{"id":"cbosa:A907587B95","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 910/18","judgmentDate":"2019-11-13","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 13 listopada 2019 r., II OSK 910/18 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3AA907587B95","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 13 listopada 2019 r., II OSK 910/18"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/A907587B95","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_910/18"},{"id":"cbosa:FD3645FE86","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 2631/17","judgmentDate":"2019-09-26","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 26 września 2019 r., II OSK 2631/17 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3AFD3645FE86","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 26 września 2019 r., II OSK 2631/17"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/FD3645FE86","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_2631/17"},{"id":"cbosa:01AE2AF89A","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Wojewódzki Sąd Administracyjny w Rzeszowie","docket":"II SAB/Rz 14/19","judgmentDate":"2019-03-26","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok WSA w Rzeszowie","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok WSA w Rzeszowie z 26 marca 2019 r., II SAB/Rz 14/19 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A01AE2AF89A","designation":"wyrok Wojewódzkiego Sądu Administracyjnego w Rzeszowie z dnia 26 marca 2019 r., II SAB/Rz 14/19"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/01AE2AF89A","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/wojewodzki-sad-administracyjny-w-rzeszowie/II_SAB/Rz_14/19"},{"id":"cbosa:B2A211E1CB","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 1217/15","judgmentDate":"2017-01-13","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 13 stycznia 2017 r., II OSK 1217/15 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3AB2A211E1CB","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 13 stycznia 2017 r., II OSK 1217/15"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/B2A211E1CB","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_1217/15"},{"id":"cbosa:1578AC06B3","courtType":"ADMIN","courtName":"Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny","docket":"II OSK 1251/16","judgmentDate":"2016-12-15","documentKind":"ruling","judgmentType":"Wyrok NSA","textStatus":"ok","citation":{"text":"Wyrok NSA z 15 grudnia 2016 r., II OSK 1251/16 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, za: JuDDGES/pl-nsa, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/cbosa%3A1578AC06B3","designation":"wyrok Naczelnego Sądu Administracyjnego z dnia 15 grudnia 2016 r., II OSK 1251/16"},"source":"plnsa","sourceUrl":"https://orzeczenia.nsa.gov.pl/doc/1578AC06B3","anonymization":"documented","matchedPaths":["arti(31)"],"origin":["SOURCE"],"pageUrl":"https://pelnora.app/orzeczenia/naczelny-sad-administracyjny/II_OSK_1251/16"}],"provenance":{"originsOnPage":{"SOURCE":20},"scope":"page","note":"SOURCE = powołanie podane przez portal źródłowy (precyzja ≈84 %, audyt 2026-09 §C.1); PARSED = wykryte naszym parserem cytowań (12/12 trafnych w audycie). Jedno orzeczenie może mieć oba pochodzenia; `matchedPaths` wymienia wszystkie dopasowane jednostki."},"sources":[{"source":"plnsa","name":"JuDDGES/pl-nsa (orzeczenia NSA i WSA z CBOSA)","author":"JuDDGES (Hugging Face: JuDDGES; repozytorium: github.com/pwr-ai/JuDDGES)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","licenseUrl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","url":"https://huggingface.co/datasets/JuDDGES/pl-nsa","note":"licencja opracowania zbioru; same orzeczenia — materiały urzędowe (art. 4 pr. aut.); szczegóły: https://corpus.pelnora.app/license"}],"knownGaps":[{"courtType":"ADMIN","scope":"dataset","note":"zbiór zamrożony na 2025-03-07 — bootstrap JuDDGES pl-nsa, brak feedu przyrostowego"}],"kind":"ruling","otherDocuments":{"total":0,"byKind":{}},"state":"OK","asOf":{"COMMON":"2026-10-16","SUPREME":"2026-10-02","ADMIN":"2025-03-07","CONST":"2026-09-22","KIO":"2026-09-28"},"license":{"id":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/license"},"citation":{"text":"Orzeczenia powołujące DU/2012/161 art. 31 (Pelnora, pelnora.app, CC BY 4.0)","license":"CC-BY-4.0","url":"https://corpus.pelnora.app/orzeczenia/by-provision?lineage=DU-2012-161&path=arti(31)"}}